Despite the passage of time since the Disha Salian case was transferred from the Mumbai Police to the CBI on September 2nd, following the Bombay High Court’s directive, the CBI has not yet conducted a custodial inquiry against any of the accused, including Rhea Chakraborty, Dino Maria, Aditya Thackeray, and Paramveer Singh. Regarding this matter, Nilesh Ojha, the lawyer representing Disha Salian’s father, Shatis shaliani, claims that the CBI cannot afford to grant these named accused any further leeway. It must take them into custody and interrogate them.
Regarding this, Nilesh Ojha argues that, based on the Bombay High Court’s order to register an FIR by the CBI and the Supreme Court’s guidelines, when prima facie evidence and forensic reports are available in serious cases like murder and gang rape, it is legally mandatory to immediately take the accused into custody and conduct custodial interrogation.
Nilesh Ojha claims that, based on the police investigation itself, he possesses numerous incriminating evidence and witnesses that could ensure justice for Disha Salian by ensuring the harshest punishment for the accused involved in her murder, such as Rhea Chakraborty, Dino Maria, Aditya Thackeray, Paramveer Singh, Sachin Vaze, etc. He has also submitted several related documents to the CBI. However, for now, he is asking the CBI to conduct a custodial inquiry based solely on the discrepancies in the Mumbai Police’s own inquiry report, which will ensure that these accused are sent to jail. Furthermore, it will be difficult for these individuals to obtain bail in this case, and they will face punishment.
Advocate Nilesh Ojha has leveled serious allegations against the Mumbai Police of fabricating a false narrative regarding the location of Disha Salian’s death (flat number and floor) and tampering with evidence at the scene. According to his petition filed in the Bombay High Court, the following major discrepancies have emerged in the police investigation:
Contradictions in flat and floor information: The police’s initial investigation and Accidental Death Report (ADR) indicated that Disha committed suicide by jumping from the 12th floor (flat number 1200/1202) of the Galaxy Regent building in Malad, which was reported to be her fiancé’s flat. However, various police documents and media statements sometimes stated that she fell from the 12th floor and sometimes from the 14th floor, which Ojha has described as fabricated.
The Suspicious Role of Flat No. 1101: Nilesh Ojha’s testimony and case documents mention flat No. 1101 (listed in the name of Preeti Rane) in the same building as a significant and suspicious location. It is alleged that Disha visited this flat on the night of the incident, but the Mumbai Police ignored or concealed the role of this flat and the people present there in their investigation.
Nine-Hour Delay in the Spot Panchnama: Ojha raised the issue before the court that the police delayed preparing the spot panchnama of the crime scene for more than nine hours. He alleges that during this time, evidence from the actual crime scene was destroyed and a fake crime scene was created.
The Status of the Bedroom Door and Lock: According to the police theory, Disha locked herself inside the bedroom of the flat and jumped out of the window. However, the Panchnama and the court hearings questioned how the police or others entered without breaking the door when it was locked from inside.
Disagreements between blood stains and fall theory: According to Ojha, despite falling from such a height (12th or 14th floor), no blood stains were found at the scene, nor were there injuries on her face or body typical of those caused by falling from such a height.
According to Advocate Nilesh Ojha, the Mumbai Police has grossly manipulated and fabricated the statements of Naveed Mujawar (whom the police presented as a pizza delivery boy/delivery agent or passerby witness) in the Disha Salian case.
Ojha highlighted the following discrepancies related to this witness in the evidence submitted to the CBI and in his arguments in court:
Contradictions in clothing color and description: According to the statement recorded in police records, the witness claimed to have seen Disha fall wearing a red T-shirt and gray pants. However, citing media reports and video evidence, Ojha stated that the same witness, in an interview given in front of media cameras, stated that Disha was wearing a gray nightgown.
Discrepancies in the timing of the incident: Official police documents record the presence of this witness and the time of Disha’s fall as around 12:30 am, while the witness himself has given different statements about the time (e.g., around 1:00 am) in public statements. According to Ojha, this time does not match the building’s CCTV footage and other records.
Allegation of being a ‘planted witness’: Ojha alleged that the police deliberately ‘planted’ this witness to protect the accused. He claims that this person is not a typical delivery boy but a worker of the political party Congress.
False about the place of fall: The police report, citing this witness, fabricated a story that Disha fell right in front of him, near the building’s compound or gate. Ojha called this completely false, stating that neither CCTV footage nor any evidence of the fall at the scene corroborates this claim.
According to Advocate Nilesh Ojha, the Mumbai Police fabricated a false narrative regarding Disha Salian’s friend Ankita’s phone calls and the timeline of Disha’s arrival and departure at the party, and ignored the call detail records (CDRs).
Based on the facts presented to the court and the media, Ojha pointed out the following key discrepancies in the police investigation:
Contradictions in Ankita’s phone calls and the timeline of the call: According to the police theory, Disha was invited to the party by her friend Ankita, and Disha arrived there with her fiancé, Rohan Rai. Ojha alleges that the times at which the police claim Ankita called Disha and arrived at Disha’s flat do not match the mobile tower locations and call records of both parties.
Mobile Phone Activeness and Data Usage: Ojha also claimed that even after Disha’s death (the night between June 8-9), her phone remained active for several days (June 9 to 17) and was used for internet data and calling. He alleges that the police did not immediately seize the phone from the scene and excluded evidence of actual conversations or chats with Ankita and other friends from the investigation.
Lies about attendance at the party and departure time: Police records show that Disha arrived at the party at Ankita’s call and allegedly committed suicide from there. Ojha says that there are significant discrepancies between Ankita’s phone calls and the CCTV footage of the building, which proves that the police fabricated a timeline to conceal the actual events and the role of other influential people present there.

